Attached are photos of the trim piece (on the left) that I had McMillan Rod and Custom make. They made two 9-1/2" pieces with two studs. Total cost, with shipping, was $70.40. They look pretty good when compared to an original piece, with the exception of the tips, which are a little more pointed that the original. I doubt anyone would notice the difference, particularly when they are on the bottom of an unrestored pump.

DSC01243.JPG DSC01244.JPG