You're right.......but ALWAYS for a refund the buyer has to pay for shipping back.....however, you would get the original shipping fee you'd be out 1 shipping charge. It's rare, but if you can absolutely prove to eBay that you got that sign and it is truly a fake...they will let you keep the sign (and tell you to destroy it) and still give you your money back. So, the guy would be out the sign.