Individual pumps left the factory painted red. If you paid more, or you purchased a large number of pumps, they would be painted the way you wanted. Old pumps were traded in and repainted for the stations that purchased used or rebuilt pumps. I have had pumps that looked like they had been painted over ten times. Unless you want to restore the pump to Esso, the original colors don't matter. Once a pump has been sandblasted, you can paint it anything you want. There are no pump police or shows where we bring pumps to be judged, so pick the oil company you like (your father was a Shell dealer, you used to work at a Pure station, etc.) and paint it. In other words, have fun with the pump.
As far as your 86 is concerned, it was introduced in 1936. I have ads showing the pump and I have a parts/repair manual for the pump. The pump is also shown in my new gas pump identification book (due out May 10, 2002). For more information about the literature email me at: jhsim@wbel.net
For information about the new book, see my website:
www.crspub.com Jack Sim