Hello,
I am new to this forum and just stumbled upon it a few days ago while researching some signs that I purchased along with a building full of other items. Anyways, the main reason that I'm here is to see if anyone can tell me a value for this particular Humble sign. As you can see its a dealer sign. It is double sided and right at 8'x 4'. The side you see is the worst side. There are a few rust spots as you can see from the pic. I don't know where to start, as I can't find info on the RED ones.
Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Well I haven't found much more info about this sign. I have emailed pics to several people on the internet and the values range greatly. Most say they've never seen one quite like it. I've had offers from $250 on up to $1200.
Hopefully one of the experts on here can help.

Don't know value but if I had a $1200 offer on it it would have a new owner sign is huge...

I woulda sold it for 1200 as fast as it came out of their mouth. That's insane.

I have no problem selling it for $1200. I just don't want to leave any money on the table if its worth considerably more.

I don't give value estimates in dollars on here.Rather,I'll just give you a few things to think about.That red oval is by no means a common sign.Reference books by Wayne and Scott show that the sign is the early version of the oval;1933-1945.

If you cross reference that red oval with their red oval pump plate,1939-1945,and research it a bit I think you will find the pump plate was used in Texas and New Mexico only.So,by extension,that sign probably had a very limited range of early usage.

To a serious Humble collector,or a collector assembling signage of companies that eventually became Exxon,that one would be a hard one to find.It is your sign,value it as you wish,but now you know a little more about it.

Old Iron,
I really appreciate your response. Thats the kind of info that I was looking for. I have owned this sign since this past Saturday and I'm not looking for a quick buck on it. But, like you say, they are not common. I have a small time business, so even leaving a few hundred on the table is a big deal to me.
Thank you once again for replying.

In my opinion, this is a 500-600 dollar sign! TOPS!
If you got a 1200 offer you better run with it! The rarity can NOT override the size on this piece...Its just too big with NO Graphics...
Your not leaving any money on the table at 1200, your getting more than its worth in my opinion.
Good Luck...

Not trying to offend or correct anyone on here but in my current experience, big signs are NOT a pariah anymore.
They are the signs that are going to be originals and not repopped almost every time, when you go to look at them. If they are still intact and in decent condition, they were owned by someone who really liked them, just the size that they are, and generally their condition is better compared to all the smaller signs of similar age.
I had the no graphics 18 foot long Associated sign that the buyer got a good deal on when they bought it because that sign is worth about $1000 more than I sold it for, if not more, but I came down in price because of the backlash on here and I should've stayed at where I priced it at in the first place. That is a great thing for the person that got it tho and I know they really appreciate that sign and were looking for it in that size.
I now have the 12foot long Dutch Boy Paints sign that is breathtaking and a joy to look at because of the graphics, colors and size. The company tried to destroy these because of the whole Lead is posinous to humans thing and the company did not want to be associated with posining their customers, so it is a sign that I am thinking is actually "rare" (probably less than 15 complete copies left in the world) because of the very limited # of these that were not destroyed by the company or the store owners. My gut feeling is that sign is worth $7-10,000 but I am hoping that another person gets a good deal from me on a sign that they have been looking for and will really appreciate.
The market is changing and big signs are becomming loved and wanted again. People are putting these things in their houses in a showcase placement, like the fine works of art that I think they are. There are also a lot of empty walls in millions of shops and pole buildings around the country. I am also getting restaurants that buy the big signs too.
I have always loved them.
I think you have a good one there and it is a great size. Not to big Not to small.
Do a lot of research, find as many comparables as you can and go with your gut as to what to price it at and if your wrong or way to far off, then you can go down in price and come to great agreement when you have a serious buyer in front of you or on line from here or somewhere else.

You do make a good point there,and I do love the Dutchboy sign you have.

I like you Man-Cave you tell it how you see it. Bigger signs are going to be going up in value the more they repop these little signs IMO. If your a new collector and you want the real thing, Go Big or Go Home! If not you can be like me and post on the value forum and never get answers from anyone. I guess you got to me "in" with the crowd on this forum to get answers..... or new of course.

Don' t let it get you down, don't get answers on alot of mine either,but do get pm's hoping to get a steal.As been said kinda got to go with your gut feeling until provided otherwise.

Thanks Tbird! I do get those Pm's as well!

Thanks guys and maybe gals. I am going to research it the best I can. I don't need to sell it right now and I know everyone has a different opinion on signs so I'm going to hold on to it for now.
I appreciate the comments and interest.

That's ONE of the reasons that I chime in every once in awhile, or maybe it's too often but...
I know that everyone on here has had different experiences in this hobby up to the present and I've come into it at a completely different time than what it was like even 5 years ago but in some ways I have had some part of this hobby since I was 7 or 8 and my other experiences in different hobbys and jobs also lend to my current experiences in this current amazing path that I have chosen to walk.
Everyone above just told it like they see it and that is GREAT!
....but the telling it low and then sending a pm to see if they want to sell it to you seems SNAKEY to me and it has happened to me before and I won't do that to someone else, so if I think I can add something intelligent to the thread that will possibly help someone out, I chime in either on the thread or by pm. I come across enough stuff around me and most of the time I can't even afford the stuff that falls into my lap much less try to grab items from people on here. I also get genuine enjoyment from hearing all the different experiences that people in this hobby have that they decide to share with us on here so in a small way it's like I'm 'buying' everything I see on here.
The experiences that anyone shares on here and the thoughts of the value that they have ARE VALID and are just as important as any others thoughts that they share on the same thread and
IN MY OPINION
no one that shares any genuine opinion as to the value that is bieng asked for, is wrong, it's just a different 'set of eyes' or another experienced members opinion.
I would hate for someone to loose money because of what I said and I also don't want someone to be out there hanging, for a long time, on to something that I said was worth too much. I just tell my opinion and I really leave it up to the person to figure out for themselves what they think because ya know what the old saying is,
Opinions are like ........, everyone has one and they ALL stink!
Thanx to all for the compliments and thanx to all the brave souls for sharing your vast expanse of experience and knowledge with us on this site and in these value threads. This site and it's members kick a$&!!

Here is the smaller version of YOUR sign...
It sold for 300 on ebay....with the ring!
http://www.ebay.com/itm/humble-oil-sign-/151021256118?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item2329917db6
The dutchboy might be a fluke because of its killer graphics, but generally large signs dont sell well at the shows or bring the money that smaller ones do...Just my opinion...

From what I have seen, the prices on big signs has gone up some. You just need to find the right person. Plus it may take a while to find that person.

Hi and welcome to Oldgas.

In my opinion, you got what you asked for in your first post as to value. I think Tom was right on with what he said. Even though people are beginning to start buying large signs, if this one was mint, I might hold out for more money. With the chipped areas if I had the generous offer that you got, I'd let it go. I think that is all the money that could ever be had for it. Again, this is just my opinion.....Dale

Heaven Forbid if someone gave you 1200. and then re-sold it for 1300.

Now that you have asked every one to price it for you people that are interested have a place to look. If I am done with something I throw out my number and sell. If I get what I ask I did not leave anything on the table. Just me but if I paid $1000 for a sign that said (Humble dealer) on it and had to explain to all my friends what that means I would feel slighted, Maybe just me but with older signs you need a graphic or words like GAS,OIL,PUMP something to make it pop.JMO

From what, I've learned from owning businesses. It is best to keep your money rolling. Sell this sign and the profit is yours. Reinvest the principle and flip the next item for a quick profit and in the long run you will be much further ahead then parking your money in one item and holding out for maximum return. Better to flip four smaller items in a week and make $50.00 on each. Then to hold out for maximum return and make $150.00 in a month.

I'm a hoarder, so I don't follow my on advice. But, then again I collect for my enjoyment and not to pay my bills.

Funny, Dave. I was thinking, "Man thats good advise, I wish I could do that." Cuz I'm a hoarder too.
I'll throw my two cents in too. I'd say 1200.00 is good money for that sign. Do you think maybe you could get much more?

Thank you all for your comments. Signs are something new to me for the most part. I've sold plenty of small signs in my store but nothing of this size. I could see where the size could actually be a liability for this sign. I also see the other side where it might be pleasing to a certain group. I may end up taking the offer because its not a bad offer whatsoever.
I've owned this sign for less than a week and it looks good hanging in my garage, lol, so I'll give it some time and see what happens.
Once again I appreciate each and every comment and opinion that yall have given. If and when I sell it, I be sure an post on here so maybe someone can use it as a reference sometime in the future.

$1200 is crazy money on that sign IMO

$600 sign, at best, in these parts

Replying to Toms post about the smaller version ending at $300. Course it did because it was a buy it now. With an auction style it might have gone higher. John